The House of Usher (2007)

Plotzle Expert · Puzzle #12 · March 16, 2026 · Drama / Horror

Six plot descriptions for The House of Usher (2007). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A woman returns to her childhood neighborhood and learns that the community shelter where she once volunteered has become a site of ritualistic gatherings led by her former mentor.
2. A genealogist researching her own ancestry discovers that her family's wealth originated from running a notorious orphanage where children were systematically abused and exploited during the Victorian era.
3. Two estranged brothers inherit their grandfather's dilapidated funeral home and find decomposing bodies hidden in the walls while preparing the building for sale to property developers in rural Pennsylvania.
4. A woman attends her former friend's funeral and reunites with her ex-lover, who suffers from a nerve condition, while she experiences apparitions and discovers a secret about the house.
5. A withdrawn architect designs luxury homes for wealthy clients but secretly incorporates structural flaws that cause psychological distress to the occupants as revenge for his own childhood trauma and displacement.
6. An elderly caretaker maintains a decaying mansion for an absent family while experiencing vivid hallucinations of the previous residents who died in a murder-suicide pact decades earlier in 1952.