The Tuttles of Tahiti (1942)

Plotzle Expert · Puzzle #14 · March 18, 2026 · Comedy

Six plot descriptions for The Tuttles of Tahiti (1942). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A marketing executive quits her corporate job to open a Polynesian-themed bed and breakfast in Maine but her complete ignorance of hospitality and coastal winters creates endless mishaps for the confused guests who arrive.
2. Two childhood friends reunite at a tropical resort for a destination wedding and spend the week drunkenly sabotaging the ceremony because they both slept with the groom during college and never told anyone.
3. Three siblings inherit their father's failing tiki bar in Florida and discover he gambled away the property deed, so they host an elaborate luau to raise enough money before the new owners arrive.
4. A perfectionist wedding planner accidentally books five ceremonies at the same beachfront venue on one afternoon and recruits her unreliable ex-boyfriend to help manage the chaos while avoiding the angry couples.
5. A man returns to an island where his family loses their plantation in a cockfight, but he salvages an abandoned ship for money, then opens a joint bank account for the family.
6. An amateur chef enters a Hawaiian cooking competition to impress his judgmental in-laws but substitutes ingredients he finds at a gas station when his luggage gets lost and the resulting dishes become accidentally popular.