Love Always, Santa (2016)

Plotzle Expert · Puzzle #1 · April 28, 2026 · Romance / Comedy

Six plot descriptions for Love Always, Santa (2016). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A widow whose husband died three years ago on Christmas Day focuses on raising her daughter, who writes to Santa asking for her mother to find love and happiness again.
2. A greeting card writer who signs all her Christmas designs as Santa receives anonymous love letters addressed to her pen name and investigates their origin while falling for her new editor.
3. Two postal workers in Vermont accidentally deliver each other's personal letters to Santa into the wrong mailboxes and begin corresponding anonymously before discovering they work together at the same sorting facility.
4. A department store Santa quits after his wife leaves him for another man but returns when a struggling single mother offers him free lodging in exchange for cheering up her lonely son.
5. A woman who ghostwrites Santa reply letters for a shopping mall begins inserting romantic advice into responses when she notices a divorced father bringing his daughter weekly to submit new wishes.
6. An event planner books a seaside resort for Christmas but discovers her ex-boyfriend now manages the property and they must collaborate on a holiday wedding while revisiting their past relationship.