The Greatest Question (1919)

Plotzle Expert · E59 · May 7, 2026 · Drama

Six plot descriptions for The Greatest Question (1919). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. An orphaned young woman who witnessed a couple commit murder as a child unknowingly seeks employment at their farmhouse years later, hoping to earn money to help her impoverished adoptive family.
2. A televised debate between two theologians about the existence of suffering becomes personal when one reveals that his opponent's published research contains plagiarized material from his deceased wife's unpublished manuscript.
3. A philosophy professor in Montreal assigns his graduate students a final exam consisting of a single unanswered question and observes how their responses reveal their deepest values and insecurities.
4. A woman interviews elderly residents at a nursing home for an oral history project and learns that one of them witnessed her grandmother's controversial decision to institutionalize her disabled sister decades earlier.
5. A man returns to his childhood home in rural Vermont to care for his father with dementia but discovers letters suggesting his mother abandoned the family rather than died as he was told.
6. An immigration lawyer in San Diego represents a client seeking asylum while her own daughter asks why she spends more time helping strangers than attending her school events and family dinners.