A Box of Faith (2015)

Plotzle Expert · E86 · May 26, 2026 · Family

Six plot descriptions for A Box of Faith (2015). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Two elementary school teachers organize a kindness challenge where students anonymously exchange uplifting messages in shoeboxes, but the project unexpectedly helps one teacher process her recent divorce and loneliness.
2. Three siblings inherit their grandmother's attic full of vintage trinkets and compete to appraise items for auction while accidentally learning family stories that bring them closer together despite their differences.
3. An anxious ten-year-old boy believes his deceased grandmother communicates through a music box she gave him, and his skeptical older sister gradually comes to respect his healing process.
4. A retiring postal worker in a small Oregon town starts delivering handwritten blessings to residents along his route, and the community responds by organizing a surprise farewell celebration for him.
5. A sixteen-year-old homeless girl survives on the streets through her faith in God while a social worker searches for her, with both learning about love and acceptance through their eventual connection.
6. A widowed carpenter in Vermont builds decorative hope chests for his church bazaar and discovers his late wife left encouraging notes inside their old cedar chest at home.