Margarita (2012)

Plotzle Expert · E93 · June 2, 2026 · Drama / Comedy

Six plot descriptions for Margarita (2012). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A timid accountant accidentally receives someone else's mail containing romantic letters and begins responding as the intended recipient, which leads to an awkward meeting when the sender arrives unexpectedly at his office.
2. A financially struggling professional couple in an urban home fire their teenage daughter's lesbian Mexican nanny due to money problems, which triggers a chain of events resulting in the nanny's deportation.
3. Two college roommates open a mobile margarita cart in Portland but their friendship sours when one secretly sleeps with the other's recently separated mother during a catering event at her book club.
4. A suburban bartender invents a signature cocktail named after his late wife and becomes locally famous when customers claim drinking it helps them resolve long-standing personal disputes and misunderstandings.
5. A woman quits her corporate job to teach pottery classes and renames herself Margarita as part of reinventing her identity, but her teenage son finds the whole transformation embarrassing and refuses to participate.
6. An aging cruise ship entertainer returns to her coastal hometown in Florida after a public meltdown and takes a job at her nephew's struggling taco restaurant while avoiding her ex-husband's new family.