The Happytime Murders (2018)

Plotzle Original · O94 · June 6, 2026 · Action / Crime

Six plot descriptions for The Happytime Murders (2018). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Two estranged brothers in Miami inherit their father's bail bonds business and discover his client ledger contains names of people who vanished under suspicious circumstances years earlier.
2. A disgraced puppet private investigator in Los Angeles teams up with his former human police partner to solve a series of murders targeting the cast of a 1990s children's television show.
3. A Brooklyn heroin dealer attempts to leave the drug trade by opening a legitimate bakery but his former supplier arrives demanding one final shipment delivery.
4. A Portland massage parlor owner laundering money for the Russian mob keeps detailed records in a diary that gets stolen by a client during a police raid.
5. An undercover narcotics officer in Detroit maintains her fake identity for so long that she begins a relationship with a dealer's brother and loses track of her mission.
6. A paroled arsonist returns to his Nevada hometown where the sheriff assigns him community service at the fire station he once tried to burn down decades ago.