5 Years Apart (2019)

Plotzle Expert · E38 · April 8, 2026 · Comedy / Drama

Six plot descriptions for 5 Years Apart (2019). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Two former college roommates open a vintage clothing store together but discover their aesthetic visions reflect completely different decades, leading to an unintentionally eclectic storefront that attracts curious customers.
2. A man inherits his uncle's failing party supply business and learns that every item in the warehouse was purchased during a manic episode five years earlier than needed.
3. A corporate trainer realizes his career development seminars are always scheduled exactly five years behind industry trends but his outdated advice somehow resonates with his oddball clients.
4. A recently divorced food blogger rents a beach cottage for the summer and befriends her landlord's chatty daughter, who insists they celebrate half-birthdays together every month.
5. A woman recovering from alcoholism volunteers at her old high school's reunion committee and accidentally reconnects with the teacher she once had an affair with as a student.
6. Two estranged brothers born on the same day five years apart unexpectedly encounter each other at their family vacation home, where they have wildly different expectations for their shared birthday weekend.