Small Town Wisconsin (2020)

Plotzle Expert · Puzzle #7 · May 9, 2026 · Drama / Comedy

Six plot descriptions for Small Town Wisconsin (2020). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Three middle-aged women reunite in their Wisconsin hometown for their former teacher's retirement party and spend the night reliving their shared history of poor romantic decisions.
2. A high school guidance counselor returns to her Wisconsin hometown after a messy divorce and accidentally becomes the local advice columnist while living in her childhood bedroom.
3. A burned-out marketing executive quits her Chicago job and moves to Wisconsin to open a bookstore but discovers the previous owner faked his death and wants it back.
4. A father who lost custody kidnaps his son for a weekend trip to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, where their intended lighthearted adventure becomes a journey toward his personal redemption.
5. A recently sober wedding photographer covers his ex-girlfriend's marriage in a small lakeside town while his teenage daughter tags along as his reluctant assistant for the weekend.
6. Two estranged brothers inherit their late uncle's failing cheese shop in rural Wisconsin and spend one chaotic week attempting to save the business before selling it to developers.