The Night Sitter (2018)

Plotzle Horror · H64 · May 22, 2026 · Comedy / Horror

Six plot descriptions for The Night Sitter (2018). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A college dropout takes a graveyard shift watching a crime scene cleanup company's storage facility when the biological evidence inside the freezers begins regenerating and moving autonomously.
2. Two estranged siblings inherit their late father's funeral home and discover he preserved something inhuman in the basement while the new owner arrives to take possession tomorrow.
3. A recovering addict accepts an overnight caregiving job for a dementia patient in rural Maine but the elderly woman insists her dead children still visit every evening at nine.
4. A widow babysits her neighbor's precocious daughter for extra income but the child accurately predicts neighborhood deaths and expects payment in increasingly disturbing personal sacrifices from her.
5. An unlicensed therapist runs support groups from her apartment to fund her gambling debts while participants begin acting out each other's confessed traumas in violent nocturnal episodes.
6. A con artist posing as a babysitter plans to rob a wealthy occult enthusiast's home with her crew, but the reclusive son accidentally summons three witches by disturbing a prized artifact.