Serving Up Richard (2012)

Plotzle Horror · H69 · June 6, 2026 · Horror / Thriller

Six plot descriptions for Serving Up Richard (2012). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Two estranged siblings inherit their father's failing butcher shop in rural Vermont and begin selling exotic meats to save the business, attracting the attention of local authorities.
2. A widower joins a grief support group where members exchange stories about their deceased spouses, but he realizes the facilitator is collecting details to assume their identities afterward.
3. A suburban couple who practice cannibalism as a hobby lure a man to their home through a classified ad for a classic car, but their intended victim refuses to become their next meal.
4. A private chef in Seattle discovers that her wealthy client has been substituting human tissue into the meals she prepares, implicating her in his crimes when investigators arrive.
5. An aging food critic returns to his childhood town to review a new restaurant but recognizes the owner as the brother who disappeared decades ago under suspicious circumstances.
6. A catering company employee becomes obsessed with a client named Richard after a wedding reception and begins inserting himself into the man's social circle through elaborate deceptions.