Love in the Time of Monsters (2014)

Plotzle Horror · Puzzle #3 · April 25, 2026 · Horror / Comedy

Six plot descriptions for Love in the Time of Monsters (2014). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. Two sisters go to a tourist attraction where they fight against toxic monsters that are wearing bigfoot costumes in order to rescue people they care about from danger.
2. A mortician who embalms bodies in his basement apartment begins dating the sister of his latest corpse and she mistakes his nervous behavior for shyness rather than guilt about her brother's disappearance.
3. A woman attends her abusive ex-boyfriend's funeral and discovers he donated his organs to five recipients who now share his violent impulses and obsessive memories of their toxic relationship together.
4. A grief counselor develops romantic feelings for a widower in her support group while battling her own addiction to prescription painkillers and ignoring the ethical violations mounting against her practice.
5. An elderly vampire running a blood bank in Portland reconnects with his human ex-wife after sixty years but their rekindled affair causes territorial disputes with younger undead creatures who want him eliminated.
6. Two teenage camp counselors dressed in mutant bigfoot costumes for a theme park fall in love but accidentally release a bio-engineered plague that turns visitors into cannibalistic versions of themselves.