From Beyond the Grave (1974)

Plotzle Horror · Puzzle #9 · May 1, 2026 · Fantasy / Horror

Six plot descriptions for From Beyond the Grave (1974). One is the real plot. Five are convincing fakes. Read them and guess which is real.

1. A mortician in Edinburgh begins receiving letters postmarked from a cemetery where he buried five patients who died under suspicious circumstances and later vanished from their graves.
2. Five strangers attending a grief support group in Manchester begin experiencing shared nightmares where they collectively harm someone who resembles the counselor leading their sessions each week.
3. Four customers buy or steal items from an antiques shop called Temptations Limited, and all meet terrible fates, especially those who cheat the shop's proprietor out of proper payment.
4. A photojournalist documenting abandoned asylums develops his film and sees figures in the images that weren't present when he took the photographs, figures that match missing persons reports.
5. A woman returns to her childhood village after decades away and finds the residents now worship an entity she accidentally summoned during a ritual she performed as a girl.
6. Three orphans inherit a decaying mansion in rural Maine but discover the previous owner's experiments have left something predatory living in the walls and seeking new hosts.